Would Robin Hood be ethical in Kantian ethics?

Robin Hood was a utilitarian. So, his ideas would never match with Kant, who was totally against utilitarianism. Robin Hood’ basic ethical principle stated: “to steal from the rich and give to the poor.” Although the act of stealing is immoral, helping the poor with that money is a moral act.

What would Kant say about Robin Hood?

Robin Hood’s actions would satisfy notions of Kant’s ‘good will’ as they are directly acting out a moral obligation by assisting those in need: nevertheless, the act of robbing a person is using that person as a ‘means’ to produce a result, when according to Kantian theory, people should only ever be used as ‘ends’.

Is Robin Hood ethical?

By this definition, Robin Hood is a virtuous person. He is courageous and definitely compassionate and generous. Therefore a Virtue Ethicist could argue Robin Hood’s actions are ethical, because Robin Hood possesses the traits of a virtuous person, and therefore the immoral act of theft is excused.

Is Robin Hood an example of utilitarianism?

Robin Hood’s basic ethical principle, to steal from the rich and give to the poor, appears to be the utilitarian approach. This is because he is doing an action that may not be intrinsically a ‘right’ action.

What is an example of Kantian ethics?

For example, if you hide an innocent person from violent criminals in order to protect his life, and the criminals come to your door asking if the person is with you, what should you do? Kantianism would have you tell the truth, even if it results in harm coming to the innocent person.

What was Robin Hood’s philosophy?

A more formal term for the Robin Hood principle is “cosmopolitan prioritarianism“, an ethical rule that says we should think of everyone in the world in the same way, no matter where they live, and then focus help where it helps the most. Those who have less have priority over those who have more.

What is the moral lesson in Robin Hood?

The message for our Westholme community is to know right from wrong, act with a conscience and be prepared to help those in difficulty or less fortunate than ourselves. Robin Hood would be proud of this legacy – if he truly existed!

What was Immanuel Kant ethical theory?

Kant’s ethics are organized around the notion of a “categorical imperative,” which is a universal ethical principle stating that one should always respect the humanity in others, and that one should only act in accordance with rules that could hold for everyone.

Is Robin Hood a consequentialist?

Robin Hood was a utilitarian. So, his ideas would never match with Kant, who was totally against utilitarianism. Robin Hood’ basic ethical principle stated: “to steal from the rich and give to the poor.” Although the act of stealing is immoral, helping the poor with that money is a moral act.

Is Robin Hood right?

When people today claim to be a modern day Robin Hood by stealing from the rich and giving to the poor, it is an evil person stealing from the innocent. Robin Hood was a good person stealing from the evil people. That’s the difference. Robin Hood did the right thing by betraying his country.

What was Robin Hood’s real name?

Robert Fitzooth

He thought that Robin was of aristocratic extraction, with at least ‘some pretension’ to the title of Earl of Huntingdon, that he was born in an unlocated Nottinghamshire village of Locksley and that his original name was Robert Fitzooth.

Is Robin Hood a rebel?

Robin Hood was a rebel, and many of the most striking episodes in the tales about him show him and his companions robbing and killing representatives of authority and giving the gains to the poor.

Is Robin Hood a trickster?

Here, Robin is frequently shown to be a yeoman forest trickster who toys with social rules or subverts authority, in the process righting injustice and exposing untrustworthy authority figures (especially those involved in law enforcement or the church).

How Robin Hood became an outlaw?

Robin Hood probably became an outlaw by killing a deer on a wager. Then he had slain one of the king’s foresters who threatened his life. A price was set on Robin’s head, and he went into hiding. Soon there gathered about him other bold men who had been outlawed or deprived of their inheritances.

Is Robin Hood a legend or folktale?

So, Robin did exist, but not in quite the same way as the Robin Hood we all think of, the cinematic Robin of Sherwood, Prince of Thieves! His story however, remains one of the best known tales of English folklore.

What kind of leader is Robin Hood?

The results showed that the Robin Hood character most frequently presented a charismatic/value-based leadership style across all films.

Why do we remember Robin Hood?

As well as being a fantastic archer, Robin Hood is arguably best known for stealing from the rich and giving to the poor. Being an outlaw in Nottinghamshire, Robin Hood fought for the rights of the oppressed against the sheriff.