What did Rawls mean: “rewarding moral desert as a first principle would be like having the institution of property to punish thieves”?

What does Rawls mean by moral desert?

If justice is getting what one is due, then the basis of desert must ultimately be undeserved. However, desert is a relational concept that expresses a relationship between a deserved and a basis of desert. It simply destroys the character of desert to demand, as Rawls does, that the basis of desert be itself deserved.

What does Rawls first principle mean?

The First Principle of social justice concerns political institutions: Each person has the same and indefeasible [permanent] claim to a fully adequate scheme of equal basic liberties, which scheme is compatible with the same scheme of liberties for all.

What does Rawls say about Desert entitlement?

What does Rawls think about desert and entitlement? People are only entitled to what they acquire as a result of playing by the rules we all agreed to.

What does Rawls mean when he claims that principles of justice should be those that would be chosen from behind a veil of ignorance?

Rawls suggests that you imagine yourself in an original position behind a veil of ignorance. Behind this veil, you know nothing of yourself and your natural abilities, or your position in society. You know nothing of your sex, race, nationality, or individual tastes.

What is the meaning of moral desert?

Moral desert is deserving something in moral terms for something you have done. So for instance if I murder someone, we might think that morally, I deserve to have something bad happen to me. Or if I help someone out, I deserve to be rewarded.

What is desert moral responsibility?

Understood this way, basic desert moral responsibility requires a kind of power or ability an agent must possess in order to justify certain kinds of desert-based judgments, attitudes, or treatments in response to decisions or actions the agent performed or failed to perform.

What are desert based principles?

Desert-based principles try to ensure that distributions are sensitive to the effort or contributions that people make to the social surplus. The idea is that some people deserve certain shares or outcomes because of their previous actions. So distributions should be proportionate to contributions.

What is the desert theory?

Lesson Summary. Just deserts is a theory which is designed to promote equality and fairness of sentencing for the imposition of a sentence. The principle behind just deserts is that the punishment should fit the crime. When such an instance occurs, it is said that the offender has received their ‘just deserts. ‘

What does desert mean in law?

It refers to that in conduct or character which deserves reward or punishment, or to that which is deserved: “a due reward or recompense, whether good or evil.”‘ Since criminal law is concerned with punishment rather than reward, “desert” in the context of criminal law generally signi- fies a deserved punishment-the …

What is desert in social justice?

Social desert means the equitable distribution of social rights and economic interests in accordance with the principle of distributive justice; it is the result of social empowerment.

What do you mean by the desert?

Definition of desert

(Entry 1 of 4) 1 : arid land with usually sparse vegetation especially : such land having a very warm climate and receiving less than 25 centimeters (10 inches) of sporadic rainfall annually. 2 : an area of water apparently devoid of life. 3 : a desolate or forbidding area lost in a desert of doubt.

What is a desert one word answer?

A desert is a dry, hot and sandy stretch of land with very little vegetation. Was this answer helpful?

Why is it called desert?

The noun desert (meaning “a dry region”) comes from a Middle English word meaning “barren” or “dried up,” from the Old French des(s)ert, meaning “without inhabitants.” It ultimately comes from the Latin verb dēserere, which means “to abandon or forsake” and is also the root of the verb desert.