Is there a flaw in my construction of Descartes’ argument?

What is wrong with Descartes argument?

This would also mean that the further, implicit conclusion that mind and body are really distinct could not be reached either. In the end, the main difficulty with Descartes’ real distinction argument is that he has not adequately eliminated the possibility of minds being extended things like brains.

How does Descartes argue that the external world exists?

Descartes goes on to show that the things in the external world are material by arguing that since God would not deceive him as to the ideas that are being transmitted, and that God has given him the “propensity” to believe that such ideas are caused by material things.

Why is Descartes dualism wrong?

It does not possess the characteristics required to interact with the physical. Based on this mechanistic understanding of the physical and nonphysical, it is impossible for the nonphysical to interact with or cause events in the physical. Thus, Cartesian Dualism cannot account for causality, and it must be false.

What was Rene Descartes weakness?

Weakness: – Descartes is very biased with subjects that require pure reason so this hinders his judgement towards sense perception. Strength: this explains why he loves Math & Science! :P.

Why is Descartes wrong about mind and body?

We separate the body and the mind in the first place because we doubted the existence of the external world earlier in the Meditation. Descartes also doubts the existence of our body, entertaining the possibility of our mind surviving without our body.

What are some problems with dualism?

Problems of Interaction. The conservation of energy argument points to a more general complaint often made against dualism: that interaction between mental and physical substances would involve a causal impossibility.

What is one major problem with the theory of dualism?

One problem with Plato’s dualism was that, though he speaks of the soul as imprisoned in the body, there is no clear account of what binds a particular soul to a particular body. Their difference in nature makes the union a mystery. Aristotle did not believe in Platonic Forms, existing independently of their instances.

What is Descartes argument for his view that the mind is better known than the body?

Descartes’ argue that mind is better known than body by first claiming humans as fundamentally rational, meaning “a thing that doubts, understands, affirms, denies, is willing, is unwilling,” ( Descartes, 19) he therefore argues that humans have the ability to know their proper minds clearly and distinctly.

Was Descartes right about the mind and body?

Though Descartes was no doubt right that very different kinds of things can interact with one another, he was not right in his account of how such different things as mind and body do in fact interact.

What is the mind-body problem and why is it a problem?

The mind-body problem is the problem of understanding what the relation between the mind and body is, or more precisely, whether mental phenomena are a subset of physical phenomena or not.

What was the major drawback of Descartes view of the mind-brain problem?

What was the major drawback of Descartes’ view of the mind-brain problem? It was not tested by empirical methods. Why was Descartes’ hydraulic model of brain function an important step in modern understanding of the brain? This model was a first attempt at providing a physical explanation for behavior.

What did Descartes believe?

Descartes was also a rationalist and believed in the power of innate ideas. Descartes argued the theory of innate knowledge and that all humans were born with knowledge through the higher power of God. It was this theory of innate knowledge that was later combated by philosopher John Locke (1632–1704), an empiricist.

What is the answer to the mind-body problem?

Among contemporary scientists and philosophers, the most popular solution to the mind-body problem is probably materialism. Materialists aspire to explain feelings and experiences in terms of the chemistry of the brain.

What is self for Descartes?

in the system of René Descartes , the knowing subject or ego. The Cartesian self is capable of one fundamental certainty because, even if all else is subject to doubt, one cannot seriously doubt that one is thinking, as to doubt is to think.

What can you say about the mind and body dualism of René Descartes Brainly?

Answer: Mind–body dualism is the view in the philosophy of mind that mental phenomena are non-physical, or that the mind and body are distinct and separable. … Dualism is closely associated with the thought of René Descartes (1641), which holds that the mind is a nonphysical—and therefore, non-spatial—substance.

What does Descartes say about the soul?

Descartes succeeded in eliminating the soul’s general physiological role altogether and in circumscribing its cognitive role to the human species. Descartes’s writings about death show that his concept of the soul clearly implied both mind and the immaterial principle of immortality.

Who argued that we construct the self?

philosopher Immanuel Kant

Brilliant and idiosyncratic, the German philosopher Immanuel Kant* helped create the conceptual scaffolding of modern consciousness in the areas of metaphysics, epistemology, and ethics.

Why does Descartes think the soul is immortal?

Descartes also believed that the soul existed prior to and separate from the body (see Meditation II of Meditations on First Philosophy ) and so was immortal. In his view all of reality consisted of two very different substances: matter or the physical and spirit or the non-physical.