How would a theist answer this argument against omniscience?

How could it be said that divine omniscience challenges the idea that humans have free will?

If God knows in advance how we will act, it looks as if we cannot act freely because we cannot act other than in accordance with God’s foreknowledge. Thus, it looks like God’s full omniscience and free will are incompatible.

Is omniscience logically possible?

But the logic of our language does not show how such a statement, even if it happened to be untrue, could ever be self-contradictory. That implies knowing what is by definition unknown: the non- existence of unknown facts. Hence omniscience is impossible.

Is omniscience a paradox?

Omnipotence is only one of the attributes of God which has been thought to lead to paradox; another is omniscience. Omniscience seems, at first glance, easy to define: for a being to be omniscient is for that being to know all the truths.

What is omniscient in philosophy?

Omniscience is an attribute having to do with knowledge; it is the attribute of “having knowledge of everything.” Many philosophers consider omniscience to be an attribute possessed only by a divine being, such as the God of Western monotheism.

Is free will compatible with omniscience?

The argument from free will, also called the paradox of free will or theological fatalism, contends that omniscience and free will are incompatible and that any conception of God that incorporates both properties is therefore inconceivable.

WHAT DO open theists believe?

Open Theism is the thesis that, because God loves us and desires that we freely choose to reciprocate His love, He has made His knowledge of, and plans for, the future conditional upon our actions. Though omniscient, God does not know what we will freely do in the future.

Is God omniscient?

According to this definition, God can be omniscient without having the de se beliefs of others, and whether his knowledge changes over time depends, not on the mere fact of his omniscience, but on the further question of whether he has his beliefs at temporal indices.

How do you solve the omnipotence paradox?

If a being is accidentally omnipotent, it can resolve the paradox by creating a stone it cannot lift, thereby becoming non-omnipotent. Unlike essentially omnipotent entities, it is possible for an accidentally omnipotent being to be non-omnipotent.

Can an omnipotent being be defeated?

No character is undefeatable, as only omnipotence is undefeatable (except by itself), and anything Omnipotent is more than a character. You don’t. Sorry but there’s no beating a Omnipotent character and if they’re beaten then they were never Omnipotent.

What is the argument against free will?

This article is adapted from Mark Balaguer’s book “Free Will,” an MIT Press Essential Knowledge Series title. The older argument against free will is based on the assumption that determinism is true. Determinism is the view that every physical event is completely caused by prior events together with the laws of nature.

What is the problem of evil and why is it a problem for theism?

The evidential problem of evil (also referred to as the probabilistic or inductive version of the problem) seeks to show that the existence of evil, although logically consistent with the existence of God, counts against or lowers the probability of the truth of theism.

Can God have free will?

So both God and man have the freedom (free will) to choose and act according to their respective natures. That human nature prior to the Fall included the capacity to choose evil is apparent (because we did).

Why does God allow evil?

The argument follows: If God is omniscient (all-knowing), then He possesses knowledge of all evil. If God is omnibenevolent (all-good), then He desires to overcome evil. And if God is omnipotent (all-powerful), then His ability is sufficient to permanently end the experience of evil. Therefore, evil should not exist.

Why did God create man?

God brought the world into existence and as the capstone of this good work, he created people in his image so that they could share in his overflowing love, grace and goodness through their relationships with the Trinity.

Why did God give us lips?

Explanation: god has given us eyes to see the truth and beauty of nature which really exists not to insult others but to look beyond the situations. and lips for speaking the truth and sweet words so that everyone loves to stay with u not to criticize others..

Why Reading the Bible is good for you?

Why You Should Read the Bible Regularly

First, the Bible shows us God’s character and provides us God’s revelation of himself to his people. In each section of the Bible, we see God’s holy, unchanging, faithful, gracious and loving character.

What has God given us answer?

Answer: God had made everything including the universe , which contain earth, trees , animals , even us .

Does God do all things well?

To make things good is the very nature of God. In the original act of creation, all that He made was good (He could only make good things). And likewise, the only things Christ can do are good. From the healing of the ill to the restoration of creation and the redemption of sinners, Christ has done well.

Is God in control of the earth?

The Bible teaches that God’s sovereignty is an essential aspect of who he is, that he has supreme authority and absolute power over all things. And yes he is very much active, despite our perplexity. Scripture says, God works “all things according to the counsel of his will” (Ephesians 1:11).

Who then can be saved?

He said, “For it is easier for a camel to go through a needle’s eye, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God”. (Luke 18:25). It was to this statement that the question was posed, “Who then can be saved?” (Luke 18:26).

Does God control fate?

Followers of Christianity consider God to be the only force with control over one’s fate and that He has a plan for every person. Many believe that humans all have free will, which is contrasted with predestination, although naturally inclined to act according to God’s desire.

Is destiny written by God?

No. The outcomes of your free will choices are known by God, but until you choose to commit an action or maintain or change an attitude, your fate is still in your own hands.

What does the name destiny mean in the Bible?

(Destiny Pronunciations)

In English the meaning of the name Destiny is: Certain fortune; fate. The mythological Greek god of fate.