General solutions to the generality problem?

What is the generality problem in philosophy?

The generality problem for reliabilism is the problem of determining, for any given belief, which belief-forming process type is relevant for justification-determining purposes.

What is the generality problem for Reliabilism?

The Generality Problem for Reliabilism

Argues that reliability approaches to justification are severely defective. They fail even to assert a necessary and sufficient condition for justification, much less a correct condition, if they do not identify the bearers of reliability.

What is knowledge according to Reliabilism?

Ramsey (1931) is often credited with the first articulation of a reliabilist account of knowledge. He claimed that knowledge is true belief that is certain and obtained by a reliable process. That idea lay more-or-less dormant until the 1960s, when reliabilist theories emerged in earnest.

What is Ayn Rand’s philosophy?

Rand called her philosophy “Objectivism”, describing its essence as “the concept of man as a heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute”.

How did Edmund Gettier challenge the view that knowledge is justified true belief?

In his 1963 three-page paper titled “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?”, Gettier attempts to illustrate by means of two counterexamples that there are cases where individuals can have a justified, true belief regarding a claim but still fail to know it because the reasons for the belief, while justified, turn out to …

What is an example of reliabilism?

In defending this view, reliabilists (and externalists generally) are apt to point to examples from simple acts of perception: if one sees a bird in the tree outside one’s window and thereby gains the belief that there is a bird in that tree, one might not at all understand the cognitive processes that account for …

What is reliabilism a level philosophy?

Reliabilism. Reliabilism says James knows that P if: P is true. James believes that P. James’s belief that P is caused by a reliable method.

Why is reliabilism an Externalist theory of knowledge?

Because reliabilism bases epistemic evaluations upon factors that hold true of the knower, but which they need not have psychologically available to them in forming and/or retaining a belief, reliabilism is an externalist theory.

Can the gettier problem be solved?

Solutions to the Gettier problem can take two forms. First, they can attempt to show that Gettier-type examples fail as counterexamples, and that JTB therefore emerges unscathed. The literature is replete with this kind of counter-counterexample, and such arguments are usually met with counter-counter-counterexamples.

What is the objection to solving the gettier problem by rejecting Fallibilism?

Specifically, Hetherington maintains that Turri does not respect the fallibilist constraint: his objection is that Turri’s “solution” is “covertly infallibilist” and so is irrelevant to the challenge of the Gettier problem.

What is the best response to Gettier?

A Proposed Solution

The widespread response to the Gettier Problem (as it has come to be known) has been to admit that justification, truth, and belief are individually necessary but jointly insufficient for knowledge and to propose some fourth condition on knowledge.

What is the gettier problem for dummies?

A Gettier problem is any example that demonstrates that an individual can satisfy the classical analysis of knowledge – justified true belief – without possessing knowledge.

What are gettier cases and why are they a problem for the classical theory of concepts?

Gettier problems or cases are named in honor of the American philosopher Edmund Gettier, who discovered them in 1963. They function as challenges to the philosophical tradition of defining knowledge of a proposition as justified true belief in that proposition.

What is a Gettier problem example?

Here’s another Gettier case: You have a justified belief that someone in your office owns a Ford. And as it happens it’s true that someone in your office owns a Ford. However, your evidence for your belief all concerns Nogot, who as it turns out owns no Ford.

What are Gettier examples?

Another example of a Gettier case can be developed from an example concerning whether an executive’s secretary is in his office. Suppose that she looked into the office and saw, sitting behind the desk, a figure who looked to her exactly like her secretary.

What is the conclusion Gettier is trying to defend?

Gettier’s conclusion. The Gettier Counter-examples show that the definition of knowledge given in the JTB account does not state a sufficient condition for someone’s knowing a given proposition.

How do you make a gettier case?

  1. One way to understand Gettier cases involves knowing how to make them. …
  2. Step 1: select any false proposition, P, for which some believer A has ample justification.
  3. Step 2: generalize away from P using a principle of deductive logic to a claim Q that is true but not for the reasons adduced by A in support of P.
  4. What do Gettier cases show?

    Gettier presented two cases in which a true belief is inferred from a justified false belief. He observed that, intuitively, such beliefs cannot be knowledge; it is merely lucky that they are true. In honour of his contribution to the literature, cases like these have come to be known as “Gettier cases”.

    Does knowledge equal justified true belief yes or no why why not?

    True belief is not sufficient for knowledge; since a belief can be true by accident or lucky guesswork, and knowledge cannot be a matter of luck or accident. 2. So knowledge requires justification—i.e., having sufficient reasons for one’s beliefs.

    Is justified true belief knowledge essay?

    A person cannot know a proposition that is false. Secondly a person has to belief it, you cannot know something unless you belief in it and thirdly, you have to be justified in believing it.
    Is Knowledge Justified True Belief Philosophy Essay.

    ✅ Paper Type: Free Essay ✅ Subject: Philosophy
    ✅ Wordcount: 995 words ✅ Published: 1st Jan 2015

    Why is belief important in knowledge?

    Belief is necessary but not sufficient for knowledge. We are all sometimes mistaken in what we believe; in other words, while some of our beliefs are true, others are false. As we try to acquire knowledge, then, we are trying to increase our stock of true beliefs (while simultaneously minimizing our false beliefs).

    What is the meaning of knowledge in philosophy?

    The philosophical study of knowledge is called epistemology. The term “knowledge” can refer to a theoretical or practical understanding of a subject. It can be implicit (as with practical skill or expertise) or explicit (as with the theoretical understanding of a subject); formal or informal; systematic or particular.