Does Pascal’s Wager contain any logical flaws or fallacies?

Is Pascals Wager a logical fallacy?

1 Expert Answer. Pascal’s Wager arguably contains several logical fallacies. I’d argue that it’s at least a false dichotomy–the assumption is that there is either a God who will reward you for believing, or no God at all. But there are infinite possibilities here, not just two.

Is Pascal’s wager a valid argument?

Pascal draws the conclusion at this point that you should wager for God. Without any assumption about your probability assignment to God’s existence, the argument is invalid.

2. The Argument from Superdominance.

God exists God does not exist
Wager against God Misery Status quo

What are some objections to Pascal’s wager?

So to lay out the argument behind Pascal’s wager explicitly: (1) You shouldn’t perform actions with lower expected utility over those with greater expected utility. (2) The expected utility of wagering for God is greater than the expected utility of wagering against God. (3) Conclusion: you shouldn’t wager against God.

Is Pascal’s wager a pragmatic argument?

Pascal’s Wager is the most prominent theistic pragmatic argument, and issues in epistemology, the ethics of belief, and decision theory, as well as philosophical theology, all intersect at the Wager. This book explores various theistic pragmatic arguments and the objections employed against them.

Why Pascal’s wager is wrong?

The wager is commonly criticized with counterarguments such as the failure to prove the existence of God, the argument from inconsistent revelations, and the argument from inauthentic belief.

What is Pascal’s wager simplified?

Pascal’s Wager (or Pascal’s Gambit) is the name for an idea that Blaise Pascal had. He said that it is not possible to prove or disprove that God exists. Therefore, it is better to bet that God exists.

Why is Pascal’s wager convincing?

An infinite gain will always outweigh even a finite loss or gain. Therefore, it’s always more rational to bet that God exists. As Pascal says, if you wager and win, “you will win everything.”

God really exists God really does not exist
You bet that God does not exist INFINITE LOSS no gain (or loss)

What is the many gods objection to Pascal’s wager?

The Many-Gods Objection

An initial objection is that Pascal’s wager is too simplistic. There are many religions, and believing in the God of one religion might prevent gaining the infinite rewards of another religion.

What is Pascal’s wager quizlet?

Pascal’s Wager. a gambler’s argument for religious belief. God either exists or he doesn’t, but reason will never give us an answer. that’s why one must choose blindly to believe or not to believe in God (without being able to abstain from choosing) if you choose to believe in God and he exists.

What is the role of Pascal’s wager?

Pascal’s wager, practical argument for belief in God formulated by French mathematician and philosopher Blaise Pascal. In his Pensées (1657–58), Pascal applied elements of game theory to show that belief in the Christian religion is rational.

What did Pascal say about God?

Pascal — French philosopher, scientist, mathematician and probability theorist (1623-1662) — argues that if we do not know whether God exists then we should play it safe rather than risk being sorry.

Was Blaise Pascal a Catholic?

Similarly, since Pascal was a lifelong supporter of the Catholic faith, and since he also maintained an interest in scientific and mathematical problems well after his commitment to Jansenism and Port-Royal, it seems unfair to portray his final years as a betrayal of his scientific principles rather than as an …

Who invented probability?

History of probability

In the 19th century, what is considered the classical definition of probability was completed by Pierre Laplace.

Who invented Pascal’s triangle?

mathematician Jia Xian

It is named for the 17th-century French mathematician Blaise Pascal, but it is far older. Chinese mathematician Jia Xian devised a triangular representation for the coefficients in the 11th century.

What is Pascal best known for?

He laid the foundation for the modern theory of probabilities, formulated what came to be known as Pascal’s principle of pressure, and propagated a religious doctrine that taught the experience of God through the heart rather than through reason.

Is Pascal still used?

Pascal. Developed in the late 1960s, Pascal is an imperative and procedural programming language that was originally designed for teaching programming languages. Today, it’s been mostly replaced by C, C++ and Java, but it’s still used as an introduction to programming.

How did the Pascaline impact society?

Nevertheless, the Pascaline was a historic achievement, for it demonstrated that an apparently intellectual process like arithmetic could be performed by a machine. (Of course, the Calculating Clock was also a cogent demonstration of the power of machines, but it had no historical impact.)

What does the name Pascal mean?

Easter child

Meaning:Easter child. Pascal as a boy’s name is pronounced pahs-KALL. It is of Latin origin, and the meaning of Pascal is “Easter child”.

How do you pronounce the name Pascal?

From history in english it is said as pascal pascal from french pascal. And now you know more videos here on how to pronounce more interesting names whose pronunciations.

What was Pascal’s first name?

Blaise Pascal

Blaise Pascal
Born 19 June 1623 Clermont-Ferrand, Auvergne, France
Died 19 August 1662 (aged 39) Paris, France
Nationality French
Era 17th-century philosophy

What is the meaning of Pascal in Christianity?

Pascal derives from the Latin paschalis or pashalis, which means “relating to Easter“, from the Latin term for “Easter”, pascha, Greek Πάσχα, from the Aramaic pasḥā (Hebrew pesach) “Passover” (since the Hebrew holiday Passover coincides closely with the later Christian holiday of Easter, the Latin word came to be used …

What is the meaning of paschal mystery?

The Paschal Mystery is closely linked to ideas about redemption and salvation . It refers to four ideas about the process that Jesus went through to save humanity from sin. These are his life, death and resurrection, and finally his ascension.

What is the origin of the name Paschal?

Paschal, a variant of Pascal, from Latin Paschalis, is an adjective describing either the Easter or Passover holidays.


Gender masculine
Word/name Latin
Meaning from Latin Paschalis, associated with Passover (or Easter), from Hebrew Pesach
Other names