Besides the Cartesian Circle, what flaws are there in Descartes’ use of God?

How does Descartes explain God?

In the Fifth Meditation and elsewhere Descartes says that God’s existence follows from the fact that existence is contained in the “true and immutable essence, nature, or form” of a supremely perfect being, just as it follows from the essence of a triangle that its angles equal two right angles.

What attributes of God does Descartes list?

For Descartes, thinking is an attribute of mind, extension is an attribute of body, and God’s attributes include absolute infinitude, necessary existence, immutability, eternality, omniscience, omnipotence, and benevolence.

What kind of being does the idea of God represent Descartes?

The idea of God represents something to the mind (it represents an infinite substance), and in line with traditional theological doctrine, supposing that God is non-spatial and non-temporal, the idea cannot be understood as being a visual image of God.

What is the Cartesian circle and why was it problematic for Descartes?

He then says that without his knowledge of God’s existence, none of his knowledge could be certain. The Cartesian circle is a criticism of the above that takes this form: Descartes’ proof of the reliability of clear and distinct perceptions takes as a premise God’s existence as a non-deceiver.

How effective does Descartes expect his proofs for God’s existence to be?

How effective does Descartes expect his proofs for God’s existence to be? They should convince anyone rational who is able to understand them. What other kinds of objects could we prove exist using the reasoning Descartes gives for God’s existence in Meditation 5? It only works for this one idea.

What is the source of our error for Descartes?

We make errors of judgment when we misuse our free will to believe things without sufficient evidence. It is this misuse of our free wills that is the source of human “error and sin.” This is Descartes’ answer to the metaphysical question about where error comes from.

What are the 3 arguments for the existence of God?

There is certainly no shortage of arguments that purport to establish God’s existence, but ‘Arguments for the existence of God’ focuses on three of the most influential arguments: the cosmological argument, the design argument, and the argument from religious experience.

Why after proving God’s existence does human error become a problem for Descartes?

Why, after proving God’s existence, does human error become a problem for Descartes? Because we know God is perfect and wouldn’t deceive us. he finds something that can indicate a criterion for knowledge. they sometimes deceive us.

How does Descartes use the example involving the mountain and the valley to talk about God?

How does Descartes use the example involving the mountain and the valley to talk about God? Descartes says that existence can be no more separated from God than the idea a mountain can be from the idea of a valley.

What are the 5 proofs of God’s existence?

Thomas Aquinas’ Five Ways to Prove the Existence of God

  • The First Way: Motion.
  • The Second Way: Efficient Cause.
  • The Third Way: Possibility and Necessity.
  • The Fourth Way: Gradation.
  • The Fifth Way: Design.

What are the three problems that Descartes raises to question the reliability of sense experience?

Descartes uses three very similar arguments to open all our knowledge to doubt: The dream argument, the deceiving God argument, and the evil demon argument.

What are the three things that Descartes doubts?

The First Meditation, then, is an extended exercise in learning to doubt everything that I believe, considered at three distinct levels:

  • Perceptual Illusion. …
  • The Dream Problem. …
  • A Deceiving God.

What is the Cartesian problem?

The Cartesian skeptical argument is often presented as follows: (1) If you know that an external world proposition P is true, then you know that the skeptical hypothesis SH is false. But (2) you don’t know that SH is false. Therefore, (3) you do not know that P.

What are Descartes three skeptical arguments and how do they go?

Descartes is here suggesting the following argument: (1) I cannot distinguish with certainty being awake from being asleep. (2) If I cannot distinguish with certainty being awake from being asleep, then I have reason to doubt all of my sensory beliefs. (3) So, I have reason to doubt all of my sensory beliefs.

Why does Descartes believe it is possible to doubt the senses?

Abstract. Descartes first invokes the errors of the senses in the Meditations to generate doubt; he suggests that because the senses sometimes deceive, we have reason not to trust them.

What is the problem of evil Descartes?

In the first of his 1641 Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes imagines that an evil demon, of “utmost power and cunning has employed all his energies in order to deceive me.” This evil demon is imagined to present a complete illusion of an external world, so that Descartes can say, “I shall think that the sky,